Hello Reader,
I talked last week about how having goals--especially ones that revolve around outcomes you can't control--can lead to paralysis instead of motivation. I'd just hit Send when this article, What Counts as a Bestseller, came across my desk.
Not only is it a fascinating history of how NOT based on actual sales data the New York Times Best Seller lists are (seriously, it went to court and the NYT lawyers argued that the list is "editorial content," not based on mathematics!), but it's a look at the last century of writing trends and just how much they've fluctuated over the years.
Even if you're not up for geeking out on publishing history with me, I want you to spend some time this week examining your goals and intentions around your own writing journey. Be honest, is being a "best seller" on that list? You may be shaking your head no while a tiny voice in the back of your mind whispers "Yes, oh yes please."
I get it. We spend so much time and emotional energy writing our stories. The idea of them being as important to the masses as they are to us is enough to keep us doing this work even when it's so, so hard.
Unfortunately, the truth is that we have zero control of whether we become a best seller. In fact, as the article above shows, even if we could control how many books we sold (and we can't!), it still might not be enough to "hit the list" if we're not writing the exact genre and publishing in the exact formula and impressing the exact powers that be necessary to do it.
I'm trying to reframe my feelings about this reality from angst and despair to a sense of freedom and possibility. If I cannot control the outcome, there is no reason for me to write anything other than what fills me up, makes me excited to sit down at my desk each day, and keeps me showing up for myself and my stories. I will absolutely keep working on my craft, keep examining my own biases and how they show up in my work, keep reading so that I understand the current market. But I also know I can do all that "right" and still not hit the list.
Readers need these stories of our hearts, the stories only we can tell. So we must carry on writing them, even if the orange banner, the golden stickers, or whatever outcome-beyond-our-control continues to evade us.
I'm going to keep having faith. And I hope you will too.
Warmly,
Julie
PS - My colleague Susan DeFreitas has a FREE hour-long masterclass called Fiction as a Force for Change. It's all about using the power of storytelling to change the world and it may be just the dose of inspiration you need right now. Check it out.
Julie Artz works with both award-winning and newer authors across the publishing spectrum from Big Five to small and university presses to indie and hybrid. She is an Author Accelerator-certified Founding Book Coach, a sought-after speaker and writing instructor, and a regular contributor to Jane Friedman and Writers Helping Writers, and a regular instructor for AuthorsPublish, IWWG, ProWritingAid and more. Her work as a Pitch Wars and Teen Pit mentor, a former SCBWI Regional Advisor (WWA), and her memberships in The EFA, the WFWA, AWP, and the Authors Guild keep her industry knowledge sharp. A consummate social and environmental justice minded story geek, Julie lives in an enchanted forest outside of Redmond, Washington, with her husband, two strong-willed teenagers (when they’re not off at university!), and two naughty furry familiars. She’s built a thriving book coaching business based on her values, her editing chops, and her knowledge of story. Check out her weekly newsletter, Wyrd Words Weekly, and subscribe today.
Hello Reader, I've been neglecting the "What I'm Reading" portion of my newsletter in all the busy-ness of the past few months, so today is a double-header. If you're looking for something to distract you from the news once you get your ballot in, this is the newsletter for you! Even though I'm mostly writing adult fiction these days, my love of middle grade endures. And part of the reason for that is the hope and heart that is so much a part of my favorite middle grade stories. This week,...
Hello Reader, I'm just about on the other side of a month of busy-ness and I'm not going to lie: I'm tired. But I also experienced some deep magic that has rekindled my writing spark. If you've been around here long, you know I'm almost as big a music buff as I am a book nerd. And this past weekend was something I would call once in a lifetime if not for the fact that I got to experience it last summer as well: Joni Mitchell and the Joni Jam. Bear with me, even if you don't love Joni the way...
Hello Reader, Ever since I read Cal Newport's Digital Minimalism this past spring, I've been grappling with my feelings about social media. Remember the good old days of Twitter, when we were a cozy little writing community running pitch contests, giving each other support and feedback, and tagging everything with #amwriting and #writingcommunity? At the same time, I was logging into Facebook daily to see photos of my friends and family instead of endless ads and toxic political memes. Sigh....